Two Earl Greys, Two Different Bases
Cream Earl Grey and Earl Grey Special both deliver bergamot, but they start from different leaves. Cream Earl Grey uses black tea as its base, while Earl Grey Special uses rooibos. That single difference shapes everything from caffeine to how the cup feels with milk.
Cream Earl Grey adds vanilla and cornflower petals to its black tea and bergamot. Earl Grey Special pairs rooibos with bergamot, orange peel, cornflower petals, and natural flavor. The catalog describes the first as sweet and well balanced, and the second as sharply bergamot-forward with woody rooibos notes. Neither product record includes steeping instructions, so treat any brewing method as a starting point you adjust to taste.
What the catalog confirms
- Cream Earl Grey: Ingredients: black tea, bergamot, vanilla, cornflower petals. The black tea base means this blend contains caffeine, and the vanilla explains the creamy character in the name.

Cream Earl Grey - Earl Grey Special: Ingredients: rooibos, bergamot, orange peel, cornflower petals, natural flavor. Rooibos is caffeine-free, so this cup suits evenings or anyone avoiding caffeine.

Earl Grey Special
Cream Earl Grey Tea Taste: Sweet, Smooth, and Vanilla-Led
The catalog calls Cream Earl Grey its top-rated tea and describes sweet vanilla notes blending with Earl Grey for a smooth, well-balanced cup. The flavor notes are bergamot and vanilla. If you like your Earl Grey with a soft, dessert-like edge rather than a sharp citrus hit, this is the one to try.
Because the base is black tea, Cream Earl Grey has the body to stand up to milk. The vanilla makes the cup taste rounder, so you may not need added sweetener. The 50g size lets you test the blend before committing to the 500g bag.
Earl Grey Special Bergamot: Sharp Citrus Over Woody Rooibos
Earl Grey Special is described as full of lovely sharp bergamot taste with woody notes of rooibos. The orange peel adds another layer of citrus, while the natural flavor supports the bergamot. This is the more classic, bracing Earl Grey experience, just without caffeine.
The rooibos base gives the cup a different texture from black tea. It tends to feel lighter and earthier, which can make the bergamot seem even more prominent. If you drink Earl Grey for the citrus zing, this blend delivers that without keeping you up at night.
Side-by-side: base, caffeine, and flavor
- Base tea: Cream Earl Grey uses black tea; Earl Grey Special uses rooibos.
- Caffeine: Cream Earl Grey contains caffeine from black tea. Earl Grey Special is described as caffeine-free.
- Flavor profile: Cream Earl Grey is sweet and smooth with vanilla. Earl Grey Special is sharp and citrus-forward with woody rooibos.
- Added botanicals: Both include cornflower petals. Earl Grey Special also lists orange peel and natural flavor.
- Sizes: Both come in 50g and 500g options.
Best Earl Grey for Milk: Cream Earl Grey Wins on Body
If you take your Earl Grey with milk, Cream Earl Grey is the stronger candidate. Black tea provides the structure milk needs, and the vanilla note complements dairy or plant milk without fighting it. The catalog does not provide brewing instructions, so add milk gradually and taste as you go.
Earl Grey Special can be served with milk, but the rooibos base is lighter and the bergamot is sharper. Milk may mute the citrus you are drinking the tea for. Try it without milk first to see whether you enjoy the bright bergamot and woody rooibos as they are.
Creamy Earl Grey Loose Leaf: What to Expect from the 50g and 500g Bags
Both teas are sold as loose leaf in 50g and 500g sizes. The 50g bag is a low-commitment way to decide whether the vanilla-forward Cream Earl Grey or the sharper Earl Grey Special suits your daily routine. The 500g bag makes more sense once you know you like a blend and want to keep it stocked.
The catalog does not state how many cups each size yields, because that depends on how much leaf you use per cup. Start with a small amount and adjust.
How to Choose Between Them
Choose Cream Earl Grey if you want a caffeinated black tea with a smooth, vanilla-sweet character and you plan to add milk. Choose Earl Grey Special if you want caffeine-free drinking, a sharper bergamot hit, or a lighter-bodied cup with woody rooibos notes.
If you are unsure, buy the 50g size of each and compare them side by side. The catalog does not include steeping times or temperatures, so brew both to your usual strength and judge the flavor from there.



