One Is Rooibos-Based, the Other Is True Black Tea
The first decision between Chai and Cowboy Earl Grey is caffeine. Cowboy Earl Grey lists black tea and green tea as its base, so it contains caffeine from both. Chai lists rooibos as its base, which is naturally caffeine-free. If you want a morning lift, Cowboy Earl Grey is the direct choice. If you are cutting back on caffeine but still want a spiced, full-bodied cup, Chai fits that role.
This is not a small technicality. It changes when and why you reach for each blend. Cowboy Earl Grey suits a wake-up cup or an afternoon pick-me-up. Chai works as a morning drink for anyone avoiding caffeine, or as an evening cup when you want spice without stimulation.
What Each Blend Is Built On
- Cowboy Earl Grey: Ingredients: black tea, bergamot, green tea, cornflower petals, natural flavours. The black and green tea base supplies caffeine and a strong bergamot-forward flavor.

Cowboy Earl Grey - Chai: Ingredients: rooibos, cinnamon pieces, cardamom, ginger pieces, anise star, orange peels, peppercorns and cloves. Rooibos replaces caffeine with a full-bodied, spice-heavy base.

Chai
Citrus-Forward vs Spice-Dominant Flavor
Cowboy Earl Grey is a citrus tea first. The catalog describes it as a classic strong Earl Grey with added Gunpowder green tea for a citrus spin, and the flavor note is bergamot (strong). You get a sharp, aromatic bergamot hit over a black tea backbone, with green tea adding a lighter edge. Cornflower petals are in the blend, though they are primarily visual.
Chai is the opposite approach. The catalog calls it a traditional balanced blend of spices with strong notes of cinnamon and cardamom, full-bodied and well-complimented by the rooibos base. The ingredient list reads like a spice cabinet: cinnamon, cardamom, ginger, anise star, orange peels, peppercorns, and cloves. If you want a warming, spicy cup, Chai is the clear match. If you want bright citrus and bergamot, Cowboy Earl Grey wins.
Side-by-Side: Base, Flavor, and Caffeine
- Base tea: Cowboy Earl Grey: black tea and green tea. Chai: rooibos.
- Caffeine: Cowboy Earl Grey contains caffeine from black and green tea. Chai is rooibos-based, so it is naturally caffeine-free.
- Dominant flavor: Cowboy Earl Grey: strong bergamot with a citrus spin. Chai: cinnamon and cardamom over a full-bodied rooibos base.
- Best morning role: Cowboy Earl Grey for a caffeinated wake-up cup. Chai for a caffeine-free spicy morning drink or an evening cup.
Milk, Sweetener, and Serving Style
The catalog does not provide brewing instructions for either blend, so you will need to rely on your own taste or the package directions. That said, the ingredient profiles suggest different serving styles. Chai's spice-heavy rooibos base is often served with milk and sweetener, but the supplied information does not confirm a traditional method. Cowboy Earl Grey's strong bergamot and black tea base can stand up to milk, though the green tea portion may become less noticeable. If you take your morning tea with milk, both can work, but Chai's cinnamon and cardamom will likely remain more prominent.
For a plain cup, Cowboy Earl Grey delivers citrus and bergamot without additions. Chai delivers spice and body on its own, but you may want to experiment with milk or honey to soften the peppercorns and cloves.
Size and Value Options
- Cowboy Earl Grey: Available in 50g and 500g sizes. The 50g bag suits a first trial; the 500g bag makes sense if you already know you like bergamot-forward tea.
- Chai: Available in 50g and 500g sizes. Same size range, so you can compare both blends at the same quantity without committing to a large bag first.
What the Catalog Does Not Tell You
Neither product record includes steeping temperature, time, or a recommended amount per cup. That means you cannot rely on the catalog for a precise brewing method. Start with your usual approach for black tea or rooibos and adjust from there. The records also do not state whether either blend is organic, fair trade, or allergen-free, so check the packaging if those details matter to you. Cowboy Earl Grey includes natural flavours, and Chai includes peppercorns and cloves, which are worth noting if you have sensitivities.
Finally, the catalog does not provide a caffeine amount in milligrams. The presence of black and green tea in Cowboy Earl Grey confirms caffeine, but not a specific level. Chai's rooibos base is naturally caffeine-free, but the catalog does not make an explicit claim beyond the ingredient list.
How to Choose Your Morning Cup
If you want a caffeinated, citrus-forward tea to start your day, choose Cowboy Earl Grey. Its strong bergamot and black tea base are built for a morning lift. If you want a caffeine-free, spice-dominant cup that still feels full-bodied, choose Chai. Its rooibos base and cinnamon-cardamom profile make it a comfortable morning or evening option. Both come in 50g and 500g sizes, so you can try a small bag before committing to a larger one. There is no wrong answer here, only a question of whether you want caffeine and citrus or spice without the buzz.



